wine spectator v. wine amateur

several of the wine reviewed to date have also been tasted by the pros at wine spectator. here's how the ratings stack up.

2005 little penguin - sam i am 86, ws 88
2003 chateau ste michelle - sam i am 85, ws 84
2005 excelsior - sam i am 83, ws 84
2003 columbia crest grand estates - sam i am 89, ws 83
2003 snoqualmie whistle stop red - sam i am 79, ws 85

impressions:
- i am somewhat surprised at the close agreement on the little penguin, ste michelle, and excelsior.
- sam i am 86 and ws 88 are impressive ratings for the $7 little penguin cabernet.
- after retasting the columbia crest grand estates cab, i still find in complex for a wine in the $10 price range. maybe i was a little high at 89 points, but this is definitely better than an 83 point wine.
- I should try the snoqualmie whistle stop again.
- wines $10-20 averaged 86.5 points.
- wines $00-10 averaged 83.5 points.

2004 red diamond cabernet sauvignon washington state

http://www.reddiamondwine.com/

the bottom line - washington state cabernet blend. unchallenging and uncomplicated, but very drinkable.

alcohol - 13.8%
residual sugar - n/a
total acid - .58/100 ml
final pH - 3.30
blend - 93% cabernet sauvignon, 3% merlot, 2% petit verdot, 1% cabernet franc

aroma - cherry, fruity, spice, leather
flavor -fruity cherry soda with a smoky, earthy mild tannic finish. Slight bitterness.
price - $8.49
punt - 19 mm
verdict - 84

2005 excelsior cabernet sauvignon

http://www.excelsior.co.za/

the bottom line - south african cab. nothing but alcohol and light sweet dark fruit on the nose. flat up front with fizzing black cherry on the mid pallet with a lonnnng tannic, oaky, fruity finish. the finish alone is worth the $9, but loses marks for the one dimensional nose and flavor profile.

alcohol - 14.5%
residual sugar - 3.1 g/l
total acid - .60/100 ml
final pH - 3.63
blend - 100% cabernet sauvignon

aroma - alcohol, cherry
flavor -black cherry, sweet, carbonation sensation on the midpallet with a bold tannic, oaky finish with lingering fruit.
price - $8.99
punt - 23 mm
verdict - 83, WS84

2005 fetzer valley oaks cabernet sauvignon

http://www.fetzer.com/

the bottom line - california cab blend. unoffensive, but somewhat lacking in coherent structure. not great, but a very good value at the $7.49 price point.


alcohol - 13.7%
residual sugar - n/a
total acid - .62/100 ml
final pH - 3.50
blend - cabernet, merlot, syrah, carignane

aroma - green, oaky, starburst
flavor -light, fruity, blackberry soda, a bit flat up front, warms up in the middle with a nice (although somewhat bitter) long black cherry soda, oaky, tannin finish.
price - $7.49
punt - 35 mm
verdict - 83

wine blogging wednesday #34

what could be better...One wine geek, three lovely ladies, two bottles of washington state cabernet sauvignon?

my girlfriend and i hosted an impromptu blind tasting of the 2004 bridgman cabernet sauvignon and the 2004 nelms road cabernet sauvignon. both are columbia valley cabs.

i had previously tasted (and loved) the 2004 bridgman. although this blog is dedicated to the quest for an interesting and lovable $10 cab, i have come to realize that this is a target rather than a hard and fast rule (unless one wants to taste a lot of really bad cabernet).

i found the nelms road to be unobjectionable but uninteresting. the bridgman I loved. interestingly enough, the girls unanimously found the nelms road to be superior in complexity, body and quality.

if you like dry, the bridgman will be you're choice. if you like fruit forward drinkability, go for the nelms road.

washington state rocks.
columbia crest rules.

more detailed reviews of the bridgman and nelms road cabs are available below. Girls, feel free to weigh in on the comments!

thanks to Catie for hosting wine blogging wednesday at through the walla walla grape vine.

Sam

2004 nelms road columbia valley cabernet sauvignon

http://www.woodwardcanyon.com

the bottom line - nelms road is the second label of the woodward canyon winery. nelms road releases are young vineyard production or wines that didn't quite rate the woodward canyon label. I found this wine unobjectionable but too sweet for my taste and lacking in complexity.


alcohol - 14.4 %
residual sugar - n/a
total acid - n/a
final pH - n/a
blend - 98% cabernet sauvignon and 02% syrah
production - 4410 cases


aroma - fruity
flavor -sweet. blackberry, raspberry, cherry, one dimensional
price - $16.99
punt - 35 mm
verdict - 85

Cork taint on the decline

new processes have reduced the incidence of cork tainted wines from as high as 12% to less than 1%.

international herald tribune article

2004 martin ray angeline cabernet sauvignon

martinraywinery.com

the bottom line - a lot going on in this wine, but weak in the mid pallet, not balanced with an over the top oak finish.

alcohol - 13.9 %
residual sugar - n/a
total acid - 0.65%
final pH - 3.89
blend - 94% cabernet sauvignon, 5% zinfandel, 1% syrah

aroma - floral, green, sweet
flavor - cherry, blueberry, vanilla, moderate body, moderate tannins, long vanilla oak finish
price - $12.99
punt - 22 mm
verdict - 83

2004 georges duboeuf prestige cabernet sauvignon

georges duboeuf is a major french wine négociant, the largest bottler of wine from the beaujolais wine province. He is responsible for the production of 25 million cases of wine annually. This wine is from the languedoc-roussillon region in southern France.


the bottom line - unoffensive, unchallenging, uninteresting. A flat light bodied cabernet.




alcohol - 13.0 %
residual sugar - n/a
total acid - n/a
final pH - n/a

aroma - light fruity
flavor -light, sweet. Hi-C, flat, simple, "is that it?" finish
price - $9.99
punt - 22 mm
verdict - 82

2004 bridgman cabernet sauvignon

http://www.apexcellars.com/wines.php

the bottom line - A little north of $10 and you will likely have to search it out (2046 cases produced). this is an awesome and interesting young washington state wine. available at total wine on the east coast.


alcohol - 13.0 %
residual sugar - 0.2 %
total acid - 0.75%
final pH - 3.67
blend - 83% cabernet sauvignon and 17% merlot from outlook and cervantes vineyards.


aroma - blueberry, coffee, chocolate
flavor -light, sweet. fruit forward, medium body, very well balanced, smooth long finish
price - $12.99
punt - 30 mm
verdict - 91